Five hundred and twenty-seven

Giving to charity: how do you know where your money is going?

I like to donate to charities.  I am helping others.  I feel good about myself.  I get a tax receipt.  Up until now I’ve chosen the charities I do donate to haphazardly: someone I know asks me to sponsor them in a bike ride; or I come across a good cause on the internet or in an article in the newspaper; or a friend or family member is affected by a specific cause.  Sometimes I just pick it because it’s in my community and I hope I’m helping those around me.

During Good Deed Month in December, I wrote about The Science of Good Deeds and that doing something nice for someone else decreases your stress levels and helps in your physical and mental health.  I also found the more you do good deeds, the more those around you will want to help others out, and vice versa.  This refers more to actual volunteering and physical interactions, but can also refer to helping from afar (such as donating money or objects) if you feel a direct connection with the cause.

If I have the money to spare, I can only see the good in giving it to others in need.  I never really thought about how much of what I donate goes to the actual cause, though.  I knew administration took some of it, but I never really thought of that being my money.  I donated to Habitat For Humanity last year and they recently sent me an e-mail saying they were ranked an A+ in overall charity efficiency in MoneySense Magazine’s review of Canada’s largest 100 charities.  That took me to the MoneySense website and I started looking at all of the charities and their ranking.  I am a bit in shock.  Why are people being paid over $350,000 to work for a charity?  How is it possible that in some cases less than 50% of the money raised goes towards the program or that it costs over $50 (in fundraising costs, etc.) to raise $100?  There has to be something wrong with this model.

This list refers only to Canadian charities, but whichever country you live in, I’m now realizing how important it is to research what your money is used for before you give to anyone.  Some of the organizations I have donated to in the past are on this list and haven’t received very good grades in efficiency and transparency.  I work hard for my money and I don’t have a ton of it.  When I choose to give some of those dollars away, I fully expect some of it will go to the people who are working hard to make that charity run.  They of course have to make a living as well, and are doing it in a very honourable manner.  But I don’t think anyone should be earning hundreds of thousands of dollars.  And there’s got to be a way to cut the costs of fundraising.  Isn’t there?  Am I just being naive?

I am still going to donate money, because I believe in helping other people, but I’m going to do a bit more research of who I sign that cheque to from now on.

8 thoughts on “Five hundred and twenty-seven

  1. Hi Lindsay! Great post! It really is true, that so many times we feel obligated to give to something maybe on the spot – but where does our giving actually go? Two nights ago a young girl of about 13 knocked on our door collecting money so that she could go to another state with her speedskating team next month. No magazines or wrapping paper involved, just a “please help”. At least she didn’t bury the request behind a bucket of popcorn or can of peanut brittle.

    You’ve read at least part of my book sure, and I don’t want to shoot myself in the foot here – but with so many of the national organizations you have little knowledge or control over where it goes. That’s why we’ve always loved to give to local charities, whether it be a food bank, homeless shelter, or something through our church – at least we can see a pretty immediate return on our giving, and it’s helping our community too.

    Thanks for getting us all thinking. I may have shared this quote before, but it’s my favorite – and it’s appropriate: “Our lives begin to end the moment we stay silent about things that matter.” (Dr Martin Luther King, Jr)

    • I totally agree, Barry. I love the quote, and I totally think it’s great to donate to local community charities, as opposed to the bigger ones. It’s just like I always try to buy from independent shops if I can, supporting those people in my community.

      P.S. Still reading the book, but great so far! Lots to think about. I’m taking my time to let it all in, like you said.

  2. It is definitely unfortunate that funds are disproportionally spent, and it definitely depends on where their funding comes from. Having worked, and currently working for non-profits myself, there is a difference between non-profits (ones with high salaries that are allowed to make a profit), versus not-for-profits which are often not making as much money… So yes, there is a differentiation and mandate… It is unfortunate…. great post, as always! 😀


  3. Really true. In terms of donating, I usually avoid the big name charities for this reason. Go with grassroots (if you are donating globally). I know of many, like SCH in India where I was just volunteering, where 100% goes to the projects. Most grassroots orgs are volunteer run, whereas the big namers (World Vision, Plan, Habitat, etc) have huge overhead.

  4. Pingback: Five hundred and forty-eight | threehundredsixtysixdays

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s